How to make an HDR photo. Behind the scenes of “Look To The Wind”

So you’ve probably heard about HDR photography, and you may be wondering what you can do with it and why it’s so cool!!

This is not a short article but it will explain a lot about HDR photography and why its so neat. Today we’re going to talk about the editing techniques I used to create “Look To The Wind” the bride on the beach image that you probably have heard mentioned on Pro Photo Show, and maybe seen on the net. Also here are useful links for things reliant to what we’re learning today.

More of My HDR portraits, and Some of my HDR still scenes. Photomatix (my favorite tool for converting HDR images) & Hollywood Effects. (my actions that will help give them that extra pizazz. Also check out the two feature audiocasts I recorded where we talk a lot more about creating HDR images. High Dynamic Range Part 1, and High Dynamic Range Part 2

HDR is a method of taking multiple images and combining them in a high dynamic range file. Lets say you take three images of the exact same scene, at various exposure levels. Standard images are only around 8 bits each, basically meaning that their ability to correctly expose dark scenes while keeping bright scenes from getting overexposed is limited (or visa versa)

So to make an HDR you might take one image that’s two stops underexposed, one image two stops over, and one with correct exposure. Then using software you can combine the shadow and highlight details from all the images into a single image is called an HDR. An HDR is the combined bits of these images, and is usually a 32 bit image when converted. What does 32bit mean to you? It means it can contain far more shadows and highlights. Even though the actual resolution of the image is not increased the details inside it are much higher. The HDR Photography technique is most often done with nature or still life images, but I have been doing extensive experimenting with this technique in portraits as well with good results, as we’ll see today.

hdr example

So lets look at an example. In this image I took three shots of the bride on the beach using continuous shooting mode with auto exposure bracketing. This along with a model holding as still as possible, and a fairly wide angle scene made “Look To The Wind” Possible possible (click for a larger version) You can read more about HDR portrait techniques in my HDR portrait article.

There a a few ways to take the three images and make an HDR from them. First take your images in unedited raw form. You could do it with jpegs, but raw will give you the best results. Don’t correct the raw files before converting to HDR. There is a very basic tool in Photoshop for converting the images called Merge To HDR (File/Automate/Merge To HDR) This allows you to select you images, and it will combine them into and 32 bit image. You then can use tools to adjust the levels, and curves of the image mix to try and get a good result.

A better method is a tool called Photomatix that converts the raw images and gives you far better tools for correcting them. It also allows for batches. The key to a good HDR that is often messed up is correcting it wrong. Just because you have the 32 bit image doesn’t mean it’s instantly a masterpiece. Proper correction takes a little practice, but it’s key to a great image. For this reason it’s better to ose a program like photomatix, as there are far more options. You can use Photoshop Merge to HDR but the critical settings are not as good for HDR, and you’ll be stuck trying to get things corrested using only curves levels ect. One VERY Important adjustment that photoshop lacks is called “Light Smoothing” and it allows you to control the balance of shadows and highlights.

You may be thinking… Isn’t the purpose of an HDR to allow everything to be exposed? The answer is yes and no. HDR’s allow you to have Controll over the image in ways otherwise not possible, and essentially to have whatever part of the scene bright that you want to be bright. But to have proper depth and feel in image must have both shadows and highlights. The fact is that most HDR images you see on the net don’t look that great, and it’s because the creater did not understand the tools needed to correct it properly.hdr-before-edit.jpg

Here is a screenshot from photomatix of our converted HDR image before final corrections. It looks fair but is a bit washed out. The beauty is that because we now have that 32 bit dynamic we can bing out the details as needed. Once I play with the settings and get things looking pretty good I save the image out as a 16 bit tiff. Though the image may look pretty cool, chances are it still needs some more work. Even though we’ve brought out the exposure in most desired areas we still need to bring out the look and feel we want in our image. This is where I take it back to Photoshop and finish the magic. Since we’ve brought out the exposure details we need we don’t have to have it at 32 bit anymore, but I’ll usually try to keep it at 16 until I bring out the last details needed. I also save the various versions along the way in case I need to go back.

So where are we now?. The three images have been combined in photomatix, and we’ve corrected the details as best we can here and saved them out as a 16 bit tiff image. Below is what it looks like at this point. We see that though there are some great details the image still lacks snap. It looks too flat and washed out.

into-the-wind-1

So now it’s time to go back into our image editor and work on those details. This usually involves adjusting brightness, contrast, curves, levels, etc. Then I usually run Photoshop actions to get some amazing looking effects. My Hollywood Effects action set has some actions that work well on HDR images so you can check them out if you need some good effects too add some pizazz. Just some effects that make it POP and look great.

So what do we get after all this?? Behold.”Look The Wind” This is not only an HDR, but and HDR portrait. It will take some practice, but when your looking for that super image it’s well worth it. (click for a large version)

Gavin Seim’s Look To The Wind HDR

Yes it looks like a whole different image than the one we had when we started, but this is how it was made. The key was correcting the dynamic range properly to start with (what we did in photomatix) then using proper exposure and contract corrections in photoshop. Finally the beauty was topped off with some burning and dodging, and actions that gave us a more punchy sharp look, and subtle glowing effect.

So, some last questions and answers.

Q. Why did we go to all the hassle to make this 32 but HDR, and eventuallt saved back to a jpeg which in onlt 8 bits again.

A. There is no other way to do it. By making the 32 bit image we were able to pull the details in that we wanted. After editing we could save it back out as a standard jpeg because we allready took what we needed, and we need to go back to jepg in the end for camaptibilty sake.

Q. Whay cant I just take a single image and save it a various expore levels then convert it to and HDR.

A. You can, and some people do this but it;s not a true HDR. It may look cool but you will never have the detail that you can get by combining actual exposures because your taking an aimge and trying to pull something out that was not there in the first place.

Q. Can I correct raw files before I convert to HDR, andm ake editing easier.

A. Not really. I raw correction is not saved direct in the file, but as add on data. The HDR coversion basiclly overlooks this and takes the plain to imges to make the HDR. You could edit jpegs and use them to make yyour HDR, but using raw files to start with really is better.

Q. Is it better to take more than three exposure when making an HDR photo.

A. I usually only take thee exposures because it allows me to us auto exposure bracketing and take the shows fast in continues shooting mode. In still shots you can take more an sometimes it might give you abit more range, but it’s not essential. For portraits to pretty much have to use that fast auto mode sinve a person can’t hold still very well.

Here is my HDR workflow

  • 1.take three or more images at varied exposure settings and cover them to 32bit HDR images (I use the photmatix batch mode if I’m doing a group of them)
  • 2. correct the details on the image to make the balance of highlights, shadows, and contreact as good as possible.
  • 3. Take the image into Photshop (or other editor) and do the final correction like color tones, saturations, curves. contrast etc and then add final effect like glows.

Have fun… Gavin Seim

 

[tags]photography, HDR, actions, high, dynamic, range, adobe, portraits[/tags]
Images and written content copyright Gavin Seim 2007.

Share/Save/Bookmark

8 Responses to “How to make an HDR photo. Behind the scenes of “Look To The Wind””


  1. 1 Keith

    Gavin,
    I’m really glad you posted this. I’ve been meaning to try HDR more but haven’t had a chance to. From what little experience I do have with Photomatix though, I am going to have to disagree with you on one point: Not being able to do RAW correction before starting the HDR process. I don’t have the program on this computer so my details may be off a bit.
    First, there is an area when selecting the files for the HDR that you can go in and adjust the white balance with Photomatix. If I remember right though, this is a group process and applies to all the images in RAW format that you may be using.
    Second, Photomatix reads other file formats such as PSD and TIFF. I believe this opens up your options a bit more, but if you’re not careful, you could also be creating more work for yourself. These formats give you the ability to pre-process any file you want to use; adjust color and contrast, remove blemishes. Save them as 16bit files and you have all your information there for Photomatix to work with. As I mentioned though, don’t fall into the trap of getting too detailed with these adjustments before hand, because you can always do more finite adjustments after the HDR process.

    At least that’s my take on it.

    Long time Lurker,
    -Keith

  2. 2 Stu

    Gavin,

    I downloaded both your HDR podcasts and you sold me on it. So, I just bought Photomatix (ver 2.5.5) and have been playing around with it. However, being in northern Europe, we don’t get much sunshine until April!

    Some say that an HDR is possible using 1 x RAW file but until we get any decent light here, I’ll just have to wait.

    Tell me, there’s a box on the main screen which says “presets”. Has anyone produced any ‘free’ presets so that we might download/use/learn from their expertise with Photomatix?

    Regards,

    Stu

  3. 3 prophotoshow

    I don’t know of any off hand Stu, but I’ll keep me eyes open. The problem with tone presets in PM is that settings need to vary so much for each image. It’s not the same as making presets in LR.

    Anyway glad your playing with it. Drop by the forums if you like. It’s a good place to chat HDR, and post your work.

    Gav

  4. 4 Stu

    Gav,

    With the current climate, I may not be posting until the Spring! Many thanks for getting back to me anyway.

    Stu

  5. 5 Larry

    Gavin. Great shows on HDR - actually it was your 2 shows on HDR that got me interested in it - and i started to take my first HDRs last fall. If you are interested, here’s my Flickr gallery - featuring mostly HDR’s (I go mainly for the ‘natural’ look): any constructive criticism from you or any of your listeners would be welcome, as I’m still very much a learner: http://www.flickr.com/photos/eldubyer/

    PPS is a great show - I know you have a specific target audience in mind, but personally I would appreciate less on wedding photos and more on the ’stuff like that’ (that is, general photography and gear coverage).
    Maybe it’s time for an ‘HDR revisited’ podcast?

    .
    Respect.

    Larry

  6. 6 prophotoshow

    Thanks Larry. I checked out your flickr. Nice work. You should join us in the forums. We have a budding HDR section there.

  7. 7 Larry

    Thanks. How do I find the forum you mention? whats the URL?

  8. 8 prophotoshow

    There’s a link above up in the main navigation of the site.

    Direct URL is… http://www.prophotoshow.net/forum/

Leave a Reply